Best Coffee Makers for Brewing Performance (2024)

1

Breville Precision Brewer

Score: 9/10

Breville Precision Brewer

Offers precise and customizable brewing settings with consistent temperature control.

Brewing Performance

9/10

J

James Hoffmann

It's a somewhat smarter-than-average brewer, and its features might stack up well against other brewers in the market.

J

James Hoffmann

You can control your overall flow rate, adjusting it from very slow to much quicker, and then you can control your brew temperature.

J

James Hoffmann

The coffee maker has been running somewhat consistently. You can hear a pump running, and the water has been consistently going down.

Capacity

8/10

Large capacity suitable for families, but the water tank is not removable.

Quotes from Reviewers

J

James Hoffmann

Unusually, this device can brew up to 1.8 liters, which is certainly a lot of coffee for the home.

J

James Hoffmann

In the UK version, they've done something kind of annoying with the water tank.

J

James Hoffmann

The carafe is a thermal carafe, which is good.

Ease Of Use

7/10

Intuitive control panel with presets, but initial setup can be intimidating.

Quotes from Reviewers

J

James Hoffmann

This machine has an auto-start feature, and sometimes I grind my coffee before going to bed.

J

James Hoffmann

I do think it's very intuitive in terms of the features here and using the control panel.

J

James Hoffmann

You need to pull this out every time in order to clean it properly.

Build Quality

8/10

Sturdy design with a premium look, but can be cumbersome to handle.

Quotes from Reviewers

J

James Hoffmann

It's a very sage product. It looks like a sage product, and it feels like a safe product.

J

James Hoffmann

The brushed metals they use, the kind of plastics, and the whole design aesthetic are very sage.

J

James Hoffmann

In the UK version, they've done something kind of annoying with the water tank.

Noise Level

6/10

Not excessively loud, but vibration and buzzing can be bothersome.

Quotes from Reviewers

J

James Hoffmann

If there is one thing about this coffee maker, it is that it kind of vibrates when it's brewing.

J

James Hoffmann

The pump vibrates; it's not loud or super annoying. It's just kind of like, 'Oh, it's vibrating the whole time.'

J

James Hoffmann

The coffee maker has been running somewhat consistently; you can hear a pump running.

2

Espro P7

Score: 9/10

Espro P7

Produces clean and smooth coffee with minimal grounds, thanks to its micro-filter system.

Brewing Performance

9/10

E

ESPRO Coffee

The pour is so clean, with no dripping, and super smooth. The best part is the coffee itself.

E

ESPRO Coffee

Thanks to the micro filters on this French press, nothing gets through, and you get very smooth and delicious coffee.

Capacity

8/10

Offers flexibility with 18- and 32-ounce sizes, allowing for more coffee to be brewed.

Ease Of Use

8/10

Easy to clean and operate, though cleaning the baskets may require extra effort.

Quotes from Reviewers

E

ESPRO Coffee

It is super easy to insert. It does have that pour spout that you want to have in the right place, and it goes down so smoothly.

E

ESPRO Coffee

It's so easy and quick to clean. Just snap it together, and it's good to go.

Build Quality

9/10

Elegant and durable stainless steel construction expected to last for years.

Quotes from Reviewers

E

ESPRO Coffee

When you open it up, you see just how beautiful and high-quality it is.

E

ESPRO Coffee

I am confident this will be our French press for the next 10 years.

Noise Level

9/10

Operates quietly with a smooth plunger action.

Quotes from Reviewers

E

ESPRO Coffee

It silently pushes down instead of scraping.

E

ESPRO Coffee

My favorite part is how easy and quiet it is to push down.

3

Café Specialty Drip

Score: 9/10

Café Specialty Drip

Certified for excellent brewing with precise temperature control and multiple modes.

Brewing Performance

9/10

A

Abt Electronics

This coffee brewer meets the rigorous standards set forth by the Specialty Coffee Association's professionals and experts to achieve Gold Cup certification.

A

Abt Electronics

It brews at the proper temperature, ranging from 185 to 205 degrees Fahrenheit, achieving an optimum flavor balance.

Capacity

8/10

Brews up to 10 cups, ideal for larger households, but lacks single-serve options.

Quotes from Reviewers

A

Abt Electronics

You can enjoy up to 10 cups of your customized coffee with this coffee maker.

A

Abt Electronics

It allows you to start brewing at a preset time.

Ease Of Use

7/10

Smart features enhance usability but may complicate initial setup.

Quotes from Reviewers

A

Abt Electronics

This coffee maker has built-in Wi-Fi and works with the Smart HQ app, Alexa, and Google.

A

Abt Electronics

It has an auto-brew setting that allows you to customize your brew with parameters for temperature and strength.

Build Quality

8/10

Stylish design with high-end materials but comes at a higher cost.

Quotes from Reviewers

A

Abt Electronics

It stands 14 inches tall, 7.3 inches wide, and 12.5 inches deep.

A

Abt Electronics

It comes in a variety of finishes, allowing you to make your coffee in style.

Noise Level

8/10

Quiet operation during brewing.

Quotes from Reviewers

4

Ninja Dualbrew Pro

Score: 8/10

Ninja Dualbrew Pro

Offers versatile brewing options with strong, flavorful coffee, but lacks true espresso capability.

Brewing Performance

8/10

J

Jared Desrosiers

It can perform four different brew styles: classic, rich, over ice, and specialty.

J

Jared Desrosiers

This device actually brews K-Cups as well.

J

Jared Desrosiers

The iced coffee from this machine is one of my favorite drinks it makes; it really does a good job.

Capacity

8/10

Offers a wide range of brew sizes with an adjustable water tank for space management.

Ease Of Use

7/10

User-friendly with a clear control panel, but requires a learning curve and maintenance.

Build Quality

7/10

Sturdy construction with stainless steel accents, but requires careful cleaning.

Noise Level

8/10

Quiet operation with a minor noise issue post-brewing.
5

Breville Barista Express Impress

Score: 8/10

Breville Barista Express Impress

The machine delivers consistent espresso shots with its adaptive dosing system and built-in tamper, though it may require some trial and error for perfecting the coffee puck.

Brewing Performance

8/10

L

Lifestyle Lab

What really impresses me about this machine so far is its adaptive dosing.

L

Lifestyle Lab

It's a really cool mechanical operation that shows how the tamper flips downwards and tamps the puck.

L

Lifestyle Lab

It's quite delightful when I get a little bit of bittersweet chocolate.

Capacity

7/10

The machine has a reasonable 2L water tank and a 250g bean hopper, but its large footprint and awkward water tank design may be inconvenient for some users.

Quotes from Reviewers

L

Lifestyle Lab

The machine also comes with a cleaning kit.

L

Lifestyle Lab

The first shot from this brew group also gets hot over time.

L

Lifestyle Lab

The second thing is a little bit unfortunate.

Ease Of Use

8/10

User-friendly with automatic and manual dosing options, though it requires some know-how for optimal operation, especially for milk frothing.

Quotes from Reviewers

L

Lifestyle Lab

For the most part, it's incredibly easy to use.

L

Lifestyle Lab

It is really easy to wipe down.

L

Lifestyle Lab

It's a beautiful machine, very handsome on the countertop.

Build Quality

7/10

Durable construction with a premium stainless steel look, though some plastic components may not be as durable.

Quotes from Reviewers

L

Lifestyle Lab

It's built like a tank, and its longevity is evident now.

L

Lifestyle Lab

The components are not plasticky, but they are made of plastic.

L

Lifestyle Lab

It has the same heating element as the older machine.

Noise Level

6/10

Quiet during grinding and brewing, but can be noisy during milk frothing, reaching up to 88dB.

Quotes from Reviewers

L

Lifestyle Lab

It's quiet when grinding.

L

Lifestyle Lab

It's really quite sputtery.

L

Lifestyle Lab

If I want to top up a drink, I'm going to make a mess for you guys.

6

Toddy Cold Brew System

Score: 8/10

Toddy Cold Brew System

Produces strong, concentrated coffee with a clean brew, though setup requires attention.

Brewing Performance

8/10

T

Toddy

The Toddy also stands out for its filtration method, as it employs both a paper and fabric combination, resulting in a clean and smooth cup of concentrated cold brew.

T

Toddy

The Toddy requires a bit more attention during the setup.

T

Toddy

The reward, though, is a concentrated brew.

Capacity

7/10

Brews large batches but is bulkier and requires more space.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

Toddy

The Toddy is designed for those who like to brew in bulk.

T

Toddy

This will hold about a pound of coffee, equivalent to 9 cups or 2.13 liters of water.

T

Toddy

It might be a bit bulkier in appearance, but that extra size means you can prepare a good amount of cold brew to last throughout the week.

Ease Of Use

6/10

Simple mechanics but requires practice and patience for setup.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

Toddy

It's a really easy and convenient way to make cold brew at home.

T

Toddy

The Toddy setup is a bit more involved, especially with the draining process.

T

Toddy

If you did not use those, then obviously you're going to have a fun time trying to clean this out.

Build Quality

7/10

Sturdy design with essential components, but paper filters can be costly.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

Toddy

The newer models come with a nice lid.

T

Toddy

Lastly, you have the actual glass carafe, which is really nice.

T

Toddy

These are quite expensive, and they won't be readily available at most local grocery stores.

Noise Level

9/10

Operates quietly, ideal for noise-sensitive environments.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

Toddy

The Toddy Cold Brew System operates quietly.

T

Toddy

There is no noise during the brewing process.

T

Toddy

This is suitable for quiet environments.

7

Kalita Wave Pour Over Coffee Dripper

Score: 8/10

Kalita Wave Pour Over Coffee Dripper

Produces sweet, full-bodied coffee with a unique design for consistent brewing, though it requires practice and has a longer extraction time.

Brewing Performance

8/10

K

Kyle Rowsell

The cleato wave, as expected, is a little sweeter than these guys.

K

Kyle Rowsell

The extraction time was a little longer, and that definitely contributes to the sweetness I'm finding in the cup here.

K

Kyle Rowsell

The mouthfeel of the Kalita is a little bit heavier than that of the Origami.

Capacity

7/10

Handles up to 24 grams of coffee, suitable for larger brews, but may not be ideal for smaller or larger quantities.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kyle Rowsell

Little ones take 24 grams of coffee, and how many ounces would that be? It would be 13 and a half.

K

Kyle Rowsell

This is the 155 model, and the big ones take 42 and 700 milliliters.

K

Kyle Rowsell

The 185 model can handle up to 24 ounces.

Ease Of Use

7/10

Easy to use with standard techniques, but requires specific filters and careful pouring to avoid overflow.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kyle Rowsell

The ridges keep the filter from clinging to the side and give it a place for the water to flow down.

K

Kyle Rowsell

Pre-moisten the filter, and let's hit the GS Rio's with a nice big bow.

K

Kyle Rowsell

Standard, let's do our thing. We're going to tear the zone, right?

Build Quality

8/10

Durable construction with multiple material options, though ceramic and glass versions require careful handling.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kyle Rowsell

They have focused on creating glass versions, as well as stainless steel and ceramic options, right?

K

Kyle Rowsell

The bridges are here. Once you talk about those, the ridges keep the filter from clinging to the side.

K

Kyle Rowsell

Stainless and ceramic, right? Yeah, the bridges are here once you talk about them.

Noise Level

10/10

Silent operation typical of manual pour-over methods with no mechanical noise.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kyle Rowsell

The Kalita pour-over is nice, all right.

K

Kyle Rowsell

Your coffee is very hot and tastes good. Which one was it, Java Blender?

K

Kyle Rowsell

That was our first past career view of the Khalida pour-over, which is nice.

8

Bodum Chambord

Score: 8/10

Bodum Chambord

Produces consistently great coffee with a classic French press design, though it requires practice to perfect.

Brewing Performance

8/10

B

BODUM

It will provide you with a great cup of coffee every day.

B

BODUM

Sometimes it takes a little bit of practice to perfect this, even if you're using all the math that I've talked about here.

Capacity

7/10

Offers multiple size options, but French press sizing can be confusing and larger sizes may lead to waste.

Ease Of Use

7/10

Simple to assemble and use, but requires precise measurements and has an initial learning curve.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

BODUM

That's how easy it is to make a classic cup of French press coffee with the original French press.

B

BODUM

Spend a little time experimenting with it, because that's how you're going to get your perfect cup of coffee.

Build Quality

7/10

Durable with a vintage look, but the glass beaker is fragile and may need replacement.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

BODUM

The glass carafe is important; you want a well-designed one because that's how you'll ensure you can get a really decent cup of coffee.

B

BODUM

We have the stainless steel, and here we have the copper finish.

Noise Level

9/10

Operates silently as a manual coffee maker, with no noise during use.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

BODUM

No noise level issues are mentioned because it is a manual French press.

B

BODUM

The process is quiet because it involves manual brewing.

9

Breville Bambino Plus

Score: 8/10

Breville Bambino Plus

Fast heating and impressive steaming with good espresso quality, but lacks shot temperature adjustment.

Brewing Performance

8/10

L

Lifestyle Lab

The Bambino uses a four-hole steam wand that can be pre-programmed to reach three independently adjustable levels of temperature and texture.

L

Lifestyle Lab

Although the Bambino steams very quickly, it still cannot brew and steam at the same time.

L

Lifestyle Lab

The espresso from the Bambino is consistent with the rest of the Breville machines in terms of quality.

Capacity

7/10

Compact design with a large water reservoir, but small drip tray needs frequent emptying.

Quotes from Reviewers

L

Lifestyle Lab

There is a large removable water reservoir on the back.

L

Lifestyle Lab

The drip tray is absolutely tiny. I would highly recommend emptying it after every use just to be safe.

Ease Of Use

8/10

Simple interface and automatic milk texturing, but requires additional purchases for best performance.

Quotes from Reviewers

L

Lifestyle Lab

It has a pretty small footprint, as you can see here. It features thermojet technology, which is just incredible.

L

Lifestyle Lab

Not including a dedicated hot water outlet was a mistake.

Build Quality

7/10

Good build quality with metal components, but some parts feel less premium.

Quotes from Reviewers

L

Lifestyle Lab

Despite its relatively toyish appearance, the build quality is good, incorporating real metal and tight tolerances.

L

Lifestyle Lab

One thing that felt notably cheaper was the portafilter.

Noise Level

7/10

Quiet operation during brewing, but steam wand can be noisy.

Quotes from Reviewers

L

Lifestyle Lab

Press the steam button, and we'll see how quickly it works. Look at how much power it has—it's incredible. It also has the automatic purge feature.

L

Lifestyle Lab

Listen, listen, listen. Pump kicks on full force, okay? It's at full force.

10

Chemex Coffee Maker

Score: 8/10

Chemex Coffee Maker

Brews coffee at optimal temperatures with pre-infusion for better saturation, but requires waiting for the full brew cycle.

Brewing Performance

8/10

S

Seattle Coffee Gear

The premise of this is based on temperature; the proper range is between 195 and 204, and it achieves that.

S

Seattle Coffee Gear

This new machine, unlike the other one, did not come on. If you look, you'll see the little holes in the screen that disperse the water evenly over the ground coffee in the carafe, so that's kind of nice.

Capacity

7/10

Brews up to 8 cups and is compatible with various carafe sizes, but the included 6-cup carafe may be limiting.

Ease Of Use

6/10

Automatic brewing simplifies the process, but the carafe's weight and bulkiness can be challenging.

Build Quality

7/10

Stylish design with metal casing, but plastic parts may lack durability.

Noise Level

8/10

Operates quietly with no significant noise issues reported.