Best Running Shoes for Comfort (2024)

1

On Cloudeclipse

Score: 8/10

On Cloudeclipse

The On Cloudeclipse offers a soft and cushy landing, ideal for recovery runs, with a comfortably smooth ride.

Comfort

8/10

K

Kofuzi

I really enjoy the way the cloudtech phase makes the midsole compress. It really squishes down every time my foot hits the ground and then bounces back nicely.

K

Kofuzi

The upper is somewhat roomy, and I really have to cinch up the laces to get the fit I like.

K

Kofuzi

If you have a taller or higher volume foot, there is a potential blister point that I've identified.

Durability

8/10

The shoe is durable, with minimal wear after 100 miles, and features an improved upper and long-lasting outsole.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kofuzi

The oncloud eclipse is holding up visually quite well, which is consistent with what I'm feeling underfoot.

K

Kofuzi

The rubber on the outsole is also holding up really well.

K

Kofuzi

The concern when you're cutting holes into foam is that it will create increased wear and tear.

Traction

7/10

Good traction on various surfaces with impressive grip in wet conditions, though some wear is visible in high-wear areas.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kofuzi

It does a really good job with traction and, obviously, durability so far.

K

Kofuzi

In some of my higher wear areas, I can see that some of it is wearing down.

Weight

6/10

The shoe feels lighter than its actual weight due to its design, but it is on the heavier side for a daily trainer.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kofuzi

It felt great for all of my runs, as I've been primarily doing just easy runs.

K

Kofuzi

The weight for my size 10 1/2 is 10.5 oz or 300 g, which is really getting up there.

Support

7/10

Offers stable ride with good support, though not ideal for those needing extra stability.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kofuzi

The structured heel counter, with no heel lift for me, felt good against the Achilles, with no issues at all.

K

Kofuzi

The speedboard has a somewhat negative connotation for me, and now they're moving it down here, which is more like a mid-foot shank.

2

Nike Invincible 3

Score: 8/10

Nike Invincible 3

Extremely comfortable with excellent cushioning, though initial fit adjustments may be needed.

Comfort

8/10

B

Ben Parkes

The Nike Invincible Run Flyknit 3 is one of the most comfortable sneakers on the market.

B

Ben Parkes

The shoe is incredibly soft underfoot and provides excellent cushioning.

B

Ben Parkes

I was experiencing quite a lot of slipping at the back of the shoe.

Durability

7/10

Durable with a thick outsole, but concerns about foam longevity and not suitable for trails.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Parkes

The final change that Nike made to the sneaker was to increase the thickness of the outsole rubber.

B

Ben Parkes

I am really concerned about the ZoomX foam bottoming out, especially for certain runners.

Traction

6/10

Good road traction but struggles on wet surfaces and rough terrain.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Parkes

Overall, it had no problems with traction, even in the rain.

B

Ben Parkes

If you're on a shale or packed dirt trail, you will start to get dirt between the exposed foam.

Weight

5/10

Slightly lighter but still heavy, affecting speed and agility.

Support

7/10

Improved stability and support, but not ideal for all foot types.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Parkes

The shoe seems to have been completely redesigned, at least visually.

B

Ben Parkes

They made the midsole significantly wider around the forefoot of the shoe, which increases stability.

3

Nike Pegasus 41

Score: 8/10

Nike Pegasus 41

The Nike Pegasus 41 is highly comfortable with plush padding and a good lockdown fit, though it may cause overheating and heel slippage for some.

Comfort

8/10

B

Ben Parkes

The Nike Pegasus 41 is one of the most comfortable running shoes I've worn in the Pegasus line.

B

Ben Parkes

The tongue on these items is nice and thick, especially where the laces cross.

B

Ben Parkes

Some users may experience overheating due to the thick padding, especially in hotter climates.

Durability

7/10

The shoe offers good durability with a solid outsole, though the upper may not withstand rough conditions.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Parkes

The shoe will last a long time. Pegasus is always due, and this hasn't changed.

B

Ben Parkes

The waffle outsole is also very durable.

B

Ben Parkes

The durability test shows that sandpaper can easily wear through this material.

Traction

8/10

Excellent grip in wet and dry conditions with a thick rubber outsole, though not ideal for very slick surfaces.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Parkes

The traction in the shoe is excellent; I had no issues walking and running in wet conditions.

B

Ben Parkes

The shoe slips at 40 degrees on the grip test ramp.

Weight

7/10

Lightweight feel despite cushioning, but slightly heavier than some competitors.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Parkes

The shoe is lightweight, making it feel less clunky despite its cushioning.

B

Ben Parkes

The lack of excessive padding in the heel helps to keep the weight down.

Support

7/10

Solid fit with good arch support, though lacks a carbon plate and may not suit those used to lower heel-to-toe drops.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Parkes

The shoe offers a solid fit with good arch support, thanks to the dynamic midfoot system.

B

Ben Parkes

The wider toe box provides a stable platform for the foot.

4

Altra Via Olympus 2

Score: 8/10

Altra Via Olympus 2

Offers plush cushioning and a roomy toe box, ideal for long runs, but may feel initially stiff and warm.

Comfort

8/10

Durability

7/10

Solid durability with resilient midsole, but softer outsole may affect longevity.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Run Testers

I also think the durability appears to be quite solid here.

T

The Run Testers

The Ego Max foam should also retain its resilience nicely.

Traction

8/10

Reliable traction on various surfaces with a generous rubber outsole.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Run Testers

When it comes to the grip of that outsole, I found the traction to be quite reliable.

T

The Run Testers

There is a generous covering of outsole rubber.

Weight

6/10

Feels lighter than expected but is heavier than its predecessor.

Quotes from Reviewers

Support

7/10

Stable ride with a wide platform, but may need additional orthotic for stability.

Quotes from Reviewers

5

Nike Vaporfly 3

Score: 8/10

Nike Vaporfly 3

Comfortable with good lockdown and breathable upper, but some fit issues for narrow feet.

Comfort

8/10

B

Ben Parkes

These are very comfortable with good lockdown and no heel slip.

B

Ben Parkes

A breathable upper with a wider toe box provides more room.

B

Ben Parkes

Some users with narrow feet may experience bunching.

Durability

6/10

Durable for race day but shows early signs of wear, especially in the toebox and outsole.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Parkes

It is durable for race day and speed work.

B

Ben Parkes

There are concerns about durability due to early signs of wear.

Traction

7/10

Improved grip with new outsole design, but may wear quickly on abrasive surfaces.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Parkes

Experience improved grip and stability with the new outsole design.

B

Ben Parkes

The outsole may wear down quickly on abrasive surfaces.

Weight

9/10

Extremely lightweight, enhancing the running experience.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Parkes

It is lighter than previous models due to a weight-saving design.

B

Ben Parkes

It feels almost weightless on the foot.

Support

7/10

Offers enhanced stability but may lack lateral support for some runners.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Parkes

It is more stable with extra support on the inside.

B

Ben Parkes

It may not be stable enough for those with specific foot conditions.

6

Brooks Ghost 16

Score: 8/10

Brooks Ghost 16

Spacious fit with improved cushioning, though heel counter stiffness may cause discomfort.

Comfort

8/10

R

Road Runner Sports

The new and improved mesh upper provides the perfect balance of stretchy comfort and a secure fit.

R

Road Runner Sports

I found the Go6 to be really nicely balanced.

R

Road Runner Sports

The only thing I will say is that although the heel collars are nicely padded, there is a very stiff heel counter that bends in quite a lot. I have experienced some pressure from it on the base of my Achilles.

Durability

8/10

Durable outsole and upper, though ventilation holes may affect longevity.

Traction

9/10

Excellent grip on wet and dry surfaces, suitable for various terrains.

Weight

7/10

Lighter than previous models, but not the lightest option available.

Support

7/10

Offers stability with a stiff heel counter, but lacks midfoot support.
7

Asics Superblast

Score: 8/10

Asics Superblast

Highly comfortable for most runs, though slightly firm for recovery runs.

Comfort

8/10

B

Ben Parkes

This is the shoe I've been reaching for about 90% of the time when I haven't been testing out other shoes.

B

Ben Parkes

The foam has felt really good from the start of the run, through the middle, and to the end.

B

Ben Parkes

It's not really great for that sort of recovery or the lower end of your easy paces.

Durability

7/10

Impressive durability, though not the longest-lasting shoe.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Parkes

It's probably about halfway through its really good life now.

B

Ben Parkes

The wear on the new outsole is truly impressive.

B

Ben Parkes

This phone has not degraded much at all.

Traction

6/10

Good traction with some room for improvement.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Parkes

The grip on the Superblast is much better than that of the Nova Blast 3.

B

Ben Parkes

They have slightly redesigned the bottom, and it's somewhat diminished, though not completely. However, the grip on the Superblast is much better.

Weight

9/10

Extremely lightweight, enhancing performance.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Parkes

It's amazing how light this shoe is, given that 44-millimeter stack height.

B

Ben Parkes

The shoe weighs 288 grams, which is super lightweight.

B

Ben Parkes

It is 90 grams lighter, which is absolutely beautiful with the Superblast.

Support

8/10

Great stability with a snug fit, but sizing may vary.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Parkes

What I like most is the stability of this shoe, especially in the corners.

B

Ben Parkes

The shoe is on the wide side, making it fantastic for all the wider-footed runners out there.

B

Ben Parkes

Finally, this was not true to size for me; I had to go half a size down.

8

Hoka Clifton 9

Score: 8/10

Hoka Clifton 9

Comfortable with soft landing and breathable upper, but heel slipping and narrow toe box may cause issues.

Comfort

8/10

S

Seth James DeMoor

It is very comfortable and not a gusset.

S

Seth James DeMoor

The Clifton 9 is one of the softer daily trainers, so you can expect a squishier ride.

S

Seth James DeMoor

I enjoyed the run tonight at an easy pace, slower than 5 minutes and 32 seconds per kilometer, and I feel that this new version offers more long-distance comfort than the 5th and 8th versions.

Durability

7/10

Durable outsole but midsole creasing and early abrasion may affect longevity.

Quotes from Reviewers

S

Seth James DeMoor

In terms of durability, I'm going to go 300 miles.

S

Seth James DeMoor

I really haven't noticed much wear in this shoe so far, so it should be pretty good for many hundreds of miles.

Traction

6/10

Average traction with decent rubber coverage, suitable for roads and mild trails.

Quotes from Reviewers

S

Seth James DeMoor

The outsole traction is just average because the design is so flat.

S

Seth James DeMoor

There's a decent amount of rubber coverage, so you can expect durability levels similar to the Clifton 8.

Weight

8/10

Lighter than previous versions, but still over 8 ounces.

Quotes from Reviewers

S

Seth James DeMoor

It is slightly lighter, with just a little bit of a weight decrease from the outgoing model.

S

Seth James DeMoor

I don't love that it's measured in ounces for my size. I also don't love that, amusingly, it felt lighter.

Support

7/10

Good support with mild stability elements, but some fit issues reported.

Quotes from Reviewers

S

Seth James DeMoor

During the lockdown, nothing is moving around as I run—no bliss, no hot spots.

S

Seth James DeMoor

I was experiencing just a smidge of heel slipping in the heel pocket.

9

puma Velocity Nitro 3

Score: 8/10

puma Velocity Nitro 3

Comfortable with responsive cushioning, but slightly heavier and less breathable.

Comfort

8/10

K

Kofuzi

The tongue is quite padded, and it extends slightly further up onto the top of the foot than it did last year.

K

Kofuzi

The fit for me in the Puma Velocity Nitro 3 is a size eight in the UK. This is a very comfortable shoe.

K

Kofuzi

There's still a lot of padding at the back of the shoe, which does soak up sweat a little bit. In general, it's not the most breathable upper out there.

Durability

8/10

Durable with dual foam construction and reliable outsole, but heavier than before.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kofuzi

The Puma grip outsole, which I will discuss in the outsole section, has lived up to its reputation as a great traction compound.

K

Kofuzi

I fully expect that I could get this up to 350 to 400 miles.

K

Kofuzi

The shoe will be posted on Subwell as soon as it's available on Running Warehouse.

Traction

9/10

Excellent traction with PUMAGrip rubber, even in wet conditions.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kofuzi

The Puma grip outsole, which I will discuss in the outsole section, has lived up to its reputation as a great traction compound.

K

Kofuzi

The performance of the Puma grip was absolutely fantastic; it felt so planted.

K

Kofuzi

The redesigned rubber pattern is lighter, yet still grippy.

Weight

7/10

Slightly heavier than previous models but maintains a good balance.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kofuzi

The increased stack height of the shoe, along with the added puffiness in the heel cup, contributes a substantial amount of weight this year.

K

Kofuzi

It weighs in at 283 g or 10 oz, which is a slight increase in weight compared to the Velocity Nitro 2.

K

Kofuzi

It has increased slightly in weight, but I don't think it's the kind of weight that makes a significant difference in terms of the experience.

Support

7/10

Balanced ride with dual density midsole, but firmer than some might prefer.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kofuzi

The heel has been slightly redesigned to, I think, cradle the foot a bit more from the sides, as opposed to padding it right behind the foot.

K

Kofuzi

The dual-density midsole setup features a top layer made of Puma's Nitro foam, which is nitrogen-infused.

K

Kofuzi

The shoe is firmer than I would prefer for my daily training needs.

10

Karhu Ikoni 3.0

Score: 8/10

Karhu Ikoni 3.0

The Karhu Ikoni 3.0 offers a comfortable fit with a plush heel collar and smooth fabric, though some may find the toe box material excessive.

Comfort

8/10

S

Seth James DeMoor

The heel collar is plushly padded and covered in a silky smooth fabric that feels really good on your heel and helps prevent blisters.

S

Seth James DeMoor

The 2021 model features a refined fit through the midfoot, thanks to an anatomical lacing system and an M-lock design.

S

Seth James DeMoor

The overall score for the upper is receiving a significant deduction because there's too much material in the toe box, causing it to scrunch up.

Durability

9/10

The Karhu Ikoni 3.0 is highly durable, showing little wear after extensive use.

Traction

9/10

Offers good traction on wet surfaces with a sole that prevents stones from getting stuck.

Weight

7/10

Feels lighter than it is due to Fulcrum technology, though it is on the heavier side.

Support

8/10

Provides extra support for high arches, though less noticeable for flat-arched runners.