Best Running Shoes for Durability (2024)

1

Karhu Ikoni 3.0

Score: 9/10

Karhu Ikoni 3.0

The Karhu Ikoni 3.0 is highly durable, showing little wear after extensive use.

Comfort

8/10

The Karhu Ikoni 3.0 offers a comfortable fit with a plush heel collar and smooth fabric, though some may find the toe box material excessive.

Quotes from Reviewers

S

Seth James DeMoor

The heel collar is plushly padded and covered in a silky smooth fabric that feels really good on your heel and helps prevent blisters.

S

Seth James DeMoor

The 2021 model features a refined fit through the midfoot, thanks to an anatomical lacing system and an M-lock design.

S

Seth James DeMoor

The overall score for the upper is receiving a significant deduction because there's too much material in the toe box, causing it to scrunch up.

Traction

9/10

Offers good traction on wet surfaces with a sole that prevents stones from getting stuck.

Weight

7/10

Feels lighter than it is due to Fulcrum technology, though it is on the heavier side.

Support

8/10

Provides extra support for high arches, though less noticeable for flat-arched runners.
2

Nike Air Zoom Pegasus 40

Score: 9/10

Nike Air Zoom Pegasus 40

Durable rubber outsole expected to last up to 600 miles, offering good value.

Durability

9/10

B

Ben Parkes

The durability of the shoe has been a Pegasus staple. The rubber outsole of the shoe should last most people up to 1000 kilometers, or about 600 miles.

B

Ben Parkes

For a lot of people, they just want something you can walk into the shop for, something that's going to be predictable and dependable.

Comfort

7/10

Offers good lockdown fit and arch support but may develop hot spots during long runs.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Parkes

This new upper provides a really good lockdown fit, and I'm also getting good ventilation through the shoe.

B

Ben Parkes

I felt like it went fine for the first 45 minutes to an hour. Then, I started to develop a hot spot in my right foot, which turned into full-out pain after about an hour and 15 minutes.

Traction

7/10

Good grip on wet concrete and light trails, but not for aggressive terrains.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Parkes

It's a shoe that is really going to be most happy on the road, though you could maybe take it on some very light trails.

B

Ben Parkes

The outsole is pretty hard in here.

Weight

7/10

Relatively lightweight but not the lightest in its category.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Parkes

It has put on a tiny bit of weight, now weighing about 347 grams, which is an increase of about seven grams.

B

Ben Parkes

I weighed this on my personal scale, and at a size 9 with all the customizations I've added, my shoe came in at 9.9 ounces and 282 grams.

Support

7/10

Provides good arch support and a secure fit but lacks motion support features.

Quotes from Reviewers

3

Saucony Ride 17

Score: 9/10

Saucony Ride 17

Highly durable with quality construction, though lace loops may wear out.

Durability

9/10

S

Seth James DeMoor

The number one word that comes to mind after testing is durability, particularly in the midsole, outsole, and the upper.

S

Seth James DeMoor

I believe the durability will be very high.

Comfort

7/10

Offers a secure fit with plush cushioning, but may feel clunky and less breathable.

Quotes from Reviewers

S

Seth James DeMoor

The fit is actually somewhat similar to the previous version, version 16, which saw a lot of changes overall.

S

Seth James DeMoor

The upper does not have exceptionally high breathability, and in this colorway, during the peak of summer, if it is really hot, I foresee this upper feeling a little warm.

Traction

6/10

Provides decent grip on roads but not ideal for muddy trails.

Quotes from Reviewers

S

Seth James DeMoor

The grip here is certainly good in terms of road and tarmac.

S

Seth James DeMoor

There isn't too much rubber, and I think it will grip decently on wet pavement.

Weight

6/10

Feels heavier, not ideal for tempo runs, but balanced by midsole feel.

Quotes from Reviewers

S

Seth James DeMoor

Men's size n comes in at 9.9 ounces, men's size 9 at 8.4 ounces, and women's size 8 at a significant weight increase. However, this is offset because the new power and plus mile features make it feel not that heavy.

S

Seth James DeMoor

It's just a little on the heavier side, but it's okay.

Support

8/10

Provides good support for daily training with enhanced stability.

Quotes from Reviewers

S

Seth James DeMoor

The somewhat stiff heel counter locks you down really well.

S

Seth James DeMoor

This heel is a little bit clunky initially as the shoe is breaking in.

4

Asics Gel-Nimbus 26

Score: 9/10

Asics Gel-Nimbus 26

Features a durable outsole with improved rubber, though knit uppers may be less durable.

Durability

9/10

B

Believe in the Run

The rubber is more durable and grippy too.

B

Believe in the Run

Something that's durable can cover a ton of miles, especially with this improved rubber on the outsole.

Comfort

8/10

Offers plush cushioning and a comfortable fit, though it may feel too soft and warm in hot weather.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Believe in the Run

Everything about this shoe is comfort.

B

Believe in the Run

It's soft, it's comfortable, it's cushy, and it fits great.

B

Believe in the Run

I felt like the previous version just sort of sank in.

Traction

7/10

Improved grip with hybrid rubber, though traction is decent but not exceptional.

Weight

6/10

Feels heavier than previous models, but design improvements help mitigate the weight.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Believe in the Run

Despite weighing 11.3 oz, it felt like a faster shoe.

B

Believe in the Run

The shoe's weight increased by 4 oz this year, reaching a total of 10.7 oz or 303 g.

Support

8/10

Provides a stable ride with a wide platform, though not ideal for uneven terrain.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Believe in the Run

You experience a very stable ride throughout your entire stride because of this wide platform.

B

Believe in the Run

With this plush heel counter, it will be difficult to experience heel lift in this shoe.

5

On Cloudeclipse

Score: 8/10

On Cloudeclipse

The shoe is durable, with minimal wear after 100 miles, and features an improved upper and long-lasting outsole.

Durability

8/10

K

Kofuzi

The oncloud eclipse is holding up visually quite well, which is consistent with what I'm feeling underfoot.

K

Kofuzi

The rubber on the outsole is also holding up really well.

K

Kofuzi

The concern when you're cutting holes into foam is that it will create increased wear and tear.

Comfort

8/10

The On Cloudeclipse offers a soft and cushy landing, ideal for recovery runs, with a comfortably smooth ride.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kofuzi

I really enjoy the way the cloudtech phase makes the midsole compress. It really squishes down every time my foot hits the ground and then bounces back nicely.

K

Kofuzi

The upper is somewhat roomy, and I really have to cinch up the laces to get the fit I like.

K

Kofuzi

If you have a taller or higher volume foot, there is a potential blister point that I've identified.

Traction

7/10

Good traction on various surfaces with impressive grip in wet conditions, though some wear is visible in high-wear areas.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kofuzi

It does a really good job with traction and, obviously, durability so far.

K

Kofuzi

In some of my higher wear areas, I can see that some of it is wearing down.

Weight

6/10

The shoe feels lighter than its actual weight due to its design, but it is on the heavier side for a daily trainer.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kofuzi

It felt great for all of my runs, as I've been primarily doing just easy runs.

K

Kofuzi

The weight for my size 10 1/2 is 10.5 oz or 300 g, which is really getting up there.

Support

7/10

Offers stable ride with good support, though not ideal for those needing extra stability.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kofuzi

The structured heel counter, with no heel lift for me, felt good against the Achilles, with no issues at all.

K

Kofuzi

The speedboard has a somewhat negative connotation for me, and now they're moving it down here, which is more like a mid-foot shank.

6

Brooks Ghost 16

Score: 8/10

Brooks Ghost 16

Durable outsole and upper, though ventilation holes may affect longevity.

Comfort

8/10

Spacious fit with improved cushioning, though heel counter stiffness may cause discomfort.

Quotes from Reviewers

R

Road Runner Sports

The new and improved mesh upper provides the perfect balance of stretchy comfort and a secure fit.

R

Road Runner Sports

I found the Go6 to be really nicely balanced.

R

Road Runner Sports

The only thing I will say is that although the heel collars are nicely padded, there is a very stiff heel counter that bends in quite a lot. I have experienced some pressure from it on the base of my Achilles.

Traction

9/10

Excellent grip on wet and dry surfaces, suitable for various terrains.

Weight

7/10

Lighter than previous models, but not the lightest option available.

Support

7/10

Offers stability with a stiff heel counter, but lacks midfoot support.
7

On Cloudmonster 2

Score: 8/10

On Cloudmonster 2

Strong upper materials ensure durability, though some wear may occur.

Durability

8/10

B

Ben Is Running

The uppers of the Cloud Monster 2 are quite similar to those of The Originals.

B

Ben Is Running

In the upper durability test, using high-grit sandpaper for 10 seconds, the bird does start to work through these.

B

Ben Is Running

These are road running shoes, and the real strength of these uppers is their resistance to blunt trauma.

Comfort

7/10

Offers increased cushioning and stability, but may have minor comfort issues.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Is Running

The Cloud Monster was my favorite running shoe of the previous year in terms of daily trainers.

B

Ben Is Running

The Mido now has an increased stack height with a 6 mm addition.

B

Ben Is Running

The tongue in these items has a rather aggressive gusset.

Traction

7/10

Good grip for road running, but not ideal for slick or off-road surfaces.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Is Running

The grip on this shoe has been slightly improved.

B

Ben Is Running

The grip test ramp slips at 43°.

B

Ben Is Running

It's mainly meant for ease of glide and ease of stride.

Weight

6/10

Light materials used, but overall weight has increased.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Is Running

The materials in these are very light but also a little bit stronger.

B

Ben Is Running

The increase in the stack height makes it slightly more plush in terms of cushioning, which has resulted in a slight weight increase.

B

Ben Is Running

Altogether, this shoe has a total weight of 10.5 oz or 300 g.

Support

7/10

Improved lacing and stability, but some slippage issues.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Ben Is Running

The lacing system features an external rope lace eyelet system.

B

Ben Is Running

I did notice that with the runner's knot, heel slippage was really only mild to moderate.

B

Ben Is Running

The upper is beautiful and very comfortable, but I feel like it's a little bit uncharacteristic when worn.

8

Adidas Adizero Prime X 2 Strung

Score: 8/10

Adidas Adizero Prime X 2 Strung

Highly durable with an updated outsole, but debris collection in the midsole may affect longevity.

Durability

8/10

K

Kofuzi

The rubber has a lovely pitted texture, and the only areas that have smoothed off at all are on the lateral side of the heel.

K

Kofuzi

I've done over 50k here, and I'm not seeing any terrible wear.

Comfort

7/10

Comfortable for long runs with a spacious toe box, but fit issues and weight may affect performance.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kofuzi

The fit for me has been greatly improved with the second version of the Adidas PrimeX Strung.

K

Kofuzi

I found that it held my foot in place very securely on fast runs.

K

Kofuzi

I can't say that the upper fit is as dialed in as the V1 or as it is when the V1 is strung.

Traction

7/10

Excellent grip on roads, but less effective on wet surfaces due to debris collection.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kofuzi

The rubber is very soft and malleable, but for some reason, it never seems to wear down. It works really well on roads and pavements.

K

Kofuzi

I think the best part of the shoe this time around is from the Primax.

Weight

6/10

Feels lightweight during runs but is heavier than previous versions, impacting speed.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kofuzi

Overall, this shoe has a hefty weight of 10 ounces or 283 grams.

K

Kofuzi

It's a very fast shoe, despite the weight and the cumbersome feel of the shoe.

Support

7/10

Stable ride with enhanced support, but high stack height may cause wobbliness.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kofuzi

There is also a slightly wider base to add more stability.

K

Kofuzi

The stability wasn't world-beating on the original, and you wouldn't necessarily expect it to be on a massive kind of super foam stack shoe like this.

9

Hoka Cielo X1

Score: 8/10

Hoka Cielo X1

Excellent durability with no wear after 100 miles, but laces are problematic.

Durability

8/10

B

Believe in the Run

There's plenty of rubber here on the bottom, and you can see there's basically no wear on this shoe at all.

B

Believe in the Run

The upper material will last you a long time.

B

Believe in the Run

These laces are terrible. They tie together well, but they don't stay tied.

Comfort

7/10

Offers plush cushioning and smooth transitions but feels unstable when standing still.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Believe in the Run

The cushioning did not wear out over 100 miles; it stayed fresh and bouncy.

B

Believe in the Run

Once you're moving, it feels unstable when you're standing around, but when I was running, that thing was just smooth.

B

Believe in the Run

The upper material is a type of knit fabric. It's heavy, absorbs sweat, and tends to retain it.

Traction

8/10

Provides good grip and traction with a durable outsole pattern.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Believe in the Run

The rubber protecting this midsole is exemplary; it offers almost full rubber coverage and is very tacky.

B

Believe in the Run

I love the rubber outsole that's on here; there's a lot of it.

B

Believe in the Run

I wish they had tried to cut a little more weight and been a bit more aggressive in terms of cutouts.

Weight

6/10

Solid feel but heavier than competitors, affecting race day performance.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Believe in the Run

It is on the heavier side, and I don't use it for its intended purpose.

B

Believe in the Run

The shoe is built somewhat like a rocket tank.

B

Believe in the Run

I can definitely feel that this shoe has a little bit more bulk to it.

Support

7/10

Stable during runs but unstable when standing still, with some pressure issues.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Believe in the Run

The carbon plate provides it with a bit of stability.

B

Believe in the Run

The shoe isn't wild, and it doesn't cave in every time my foot hits the ground.

B

Believe in the Run

The downside of this arch side connecting piece is that at slower paces, like when I'm warming up and just getting ready to start the work portion of a workout, I definitely feel it.

10

puma Velocity Nitro 3

Score: 8/10

puma Velocity Nitro 3

Durable with dual foam construction and reliable outsole, but heavier than before.

Durability

8/10

K

Kofuzi

The Puma grip outsole, which I will discuss in the outsole section, has lived up to its reputation as a great traction compound.

K

Kofuzi

I fully expect that I could get this up to 350 to 400 miles.

K

Kofuzi

The shoe will be posted on Subwell as soon as it's available on Running Warehouse.

Comfort

8/10

Comfortable with responsive cushioning, but slightly heavier and less breathable.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kofuzi

The tongue is quite padded, and it extends slightly further up onto the top of the foot than it did last year.

K

Kofuzi

The fit for me in the Puma Velocity Nitro 3 is a size eight in the UK. This is a very comfortable shoe.

K

Kofuzi

There's still a lot of padding at the back of the shoe, which does soak up sweat a little bit. In general, it's not the most breathable upper out there.

Traction

9/10

Excellent traction with PUMAGrip rubber, even in wet conditions.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kofuzi

The Puma grip outsole, which I will discuss in the outsole section, has lived up to its reputation as a great traction compound.

K

Kofuzi

The performance of the Puma grip was absolutely fantastic; it felt so planted.

K

Kofuzi

The redesigned rubber pattern is lighter, yet still grippy.

Weight

7/10

Slightly heavier than previous models but maintains a good balance.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kofuzi

The increased stack height of the shoe, along with the added puffiness in the heel cup, contributes a substantial amount of weight this year.

K

Kofuzi

It weighs in at 283 g or 10 oz, which is a slight increase in weight compared to the Velocity Nitro 2.

K

Kofuzi

It has increased slightly in weight, but I don't think it's the kind of weight that makes a significant difference in terms of the experience.

Support

7/10

Balanced ride with dual density midsole, but firmer than some might prefer.

Quotes from Reviewers

K

Kofuzi

The heel has been slightly redesigned to, I think, cradle the foot a bit more from the sides, as opposed to padding it right behind the foot.

K

Kofuzi

The dual-density midsole setup features a top layer made of Puma's Nitro foam, which is nitrogen-infused.

K

Kofuzi

The shoe is firmer than I would prefer for my daily training needs.