Best Board Games for Longevity (2024)

1

Gloomhaven

Score: 9/10

Gloomhaven

Offers extensive content and replayability, but the length and complexity may deter some players.

Longevity

9/10

T

The Dice Tower

Gloomhaven offers a vast amount of content, with over 70 campaign missions and a high replayability factor due to its legacy elements and character progression.

T

The Dice Tower

The game's length and complexity might deter some players from completing it, and the setup time can be a barrier to frequent play.

Complexity

7/10

Gloomhaven offers deep strategic gameplay but has a steep learning curve and can be overwhelming.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

Gloomhaven is probably an RPG-type game, a dungeon crawler where you roll some dice, move your people on a map, and then roll some more dice to attack the enemies. However, everything you do is actually dictated by your hand of cards.

T

The Dice Tower

The game has a steep learning curve and can be overwhelming due to its complexity and the number of components.

Theme & Design

8/10

The game features an immersive theme with customization options, but some production quality issues.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

I think the setting here is a fully realized, bustling city with various activities happening, and the theme is unique. It's not the usual fantasy trope.

T

The Dice Tower

Some players may find the production quality lacking compared to other high-end games, due to issues like poorly aligned punch boards and unpainted miniatures.

Play Time

7/10

Flexible playtime management but individual sessions can be lengthy.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

Each session can be saved and resumed, allowing for flexible playtime management.

T

The Dice Tower

Individual sessions can be lengthy, often lasting 60 to 90 minutes or more, which may not suit all players.

Fun

8/10

Engaging tactical combat and character development, but complexity can detract from fun.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

The game is highly engaging with its tactical combat and character development, providing a rewarding experience as players progress.

T

The Dice Tower

The complexity and administrative tasks involved can detract from the fun for some players, especially for those who prefer less intricate games.

2

Scythe

Score: 8/10

Scythe

High replayability with different factions and expansions, but can become repetitive without them.

Longevity

8/10

B

Board Game Hangover

There is high replayability due to the different factions and player mat combinations, which offer a new challenge with each game.

B

Board Game Hangover

The game can become repetitive after several plays without expansions because the core mechanics remain the same.

Complexity

8/10

Scythe offers a deep strategic experience with a focus on engine building, though it has a steep learning curve.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Board Game Hangover

The learning curve is pretty intense, so if you are not accustomed to playing strategy, world-building, and engine-building games, there's going to be a learning curve.

B

Board Game Hangover

The game provides a rewarding challenge, as players must learn to optimize their actions and adapt to different faction and player mat combinations.

Theme & Design

9/10

Stunning artwork and unique theme, though some feel the theme doesn't fully translate into gameplay.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Board Game Hangover

The artwork and design are stunning, featuring intricate details in both the board and the pieces.

B

Board Game Hangover

The theme of an alternate 1920s Europe featuring mechs is unique and well-integrated into the gameplay.

Play Time

7/10

Grand scale experience in a short time, but setup can be lengthy.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Board Game Hangover

The game offers a grand-scale experience in a relatively short amount of time, with most games lasting around 115 minutes.

B

Board Game Hangover

The setup time can be lengthy, taking about 45 minutes.

Fun

8/10

Highly enjoyable for strategic planning enthusiasts, but lacks direct conflict.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Board Game Hangover

Scythe is highly enjoyable for those who appreciate strategic planning and engine-building.

B

Board Game Hangover

The lack of direct conflict might not appeal to players who are looking for a more combative experience.

3

Betrayal at House on the Hill (3rd Edition)

Score: 8/10

Betrayal at House on the Hill (3rd Edition)

High replayability with various scenarios, though reduced omen cards may impact replay value.

Longevity

8/10

G

Games Made Easy

The fact that, as we mentioned, you have 50 haunts, which means you could play this at least 50 times without seeing the same thing, makes it shockingly good value for money.

G

Games Made Easy

With only 9 Omens in the game, you'll frequently draw through most, if not all, of the entire Omen deck every game, putting a damper on repeat value.

Complexity

7/10

The game offers a mix of exploration and strategy with streamlined rules, but can be overwhelming for newcomers.

Quotes from Reviewers

G

Games Made Easy

Betrayal is a bit more complicated than your average gateway game, but it's well worth learning.

G

Games Made Easy

The game has 50 haunt scenarios, and each tells a different story with different victory conditions.

G

Games Made Easy

Some of the rules are still really unclear, and truth be told, if you have a game with all these different permutations, cards, and tiles trying to come together in a cohesive manner, it's going to be very difficult to eliminate all of the ambiguity.

Theme & Design

8/10

Strong horror theme with vivid components, though some may find the quality lacking compared to previous editions.

Quotes from Reviewers

G

Games Made Easy

I love it because it's like you and your friends are suddenly plunged into a Scooby-Doo episode or one of those 50s B movies.

G

Games Made Easy

The Third Edition looks bright and vivid, especially with the 45 tiles appearing more refreshed than before and featuring so much color.

G

Games Made Easy

The component quality is definitely a step down from the previous version. The toes in this edition are a little bit thinner, and the artwork isn't as nice.

Play Time

7/10

Designed for 60-90 minutes, but player elimination can cause downtime.

Quotes from Reviewers

G

Games Made Easy

It's great with three to six players; the more, the merrier, and it'll take about an hour to play.

G

Games Made Easy

Player elimination is still a massive problem in this game. You would think that after, I don't know, was it six different editions, they would have fixed this. However, a lot of the haunts mean that if you die, that's it; you are done.

Fun

8/10

Unique and thematic experience with hidden traitor mechanics, though potential imbalances can affect enjoyment.

Quotes from Reviewers

G

Games Made Easy

A simple and effective role-playing game is guaranteed to make it an evening to remember.

G

Games Made Easy

The haunts can sometimes be free-for-alls; they can have hidden traitors, or they can even be cooperative missions.

4

Harmonies

Score: 8/10

Harmonies

Wingspan offers high replayability but may lack long-term challenge without expansions.

Longevity

8/10

B

Board Game Hangover

It gets better every time you play because you discover new combos.

B

Board Game Hangover

There are limited opportunities, which makes it more challenging.

B

Board Game Hangover

The game has consistently brought happiness to the table.

Complexity

7/10

Wingspan is easy to learn with intuitive mechanics, but its strategic elements add a layer of complexity.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Board Game Hangover

This is one of those games that can be taught in less than five minutes.

B

Board Game Hangover

I believe this game is just about perfectly complex for the audience.

B

Board Game Hangover

It's easy to teach, and new gamers can really get into it and have a good time.

Theme & Design

9/10

Wingspan features stunning artwork and high-quality components, though its theme may feel abstract.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Board Game Hangover

The art was the first thing that drew me to this game.

B

Board Game Hangover

The art of this game is a major attraction, and its table presence is simply lovely.

B

Board Game Hangover

The artwork is really beautiful, and the tokens, along with the colorfulness of the terrain, are engaging.

Play Time

7/10

Wingspan offers a satisfying playtime but can feel long with more players or new learners.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Board Game Hangover

You can play it pretty quickly if you want to.

B

Board Game Hangover

This game can take a little longer, especially if you're teaching new players.

B

Board Game Hangover

A four-player count is doable, but it's a bit slow.

Fun

8/10

Wingspan is fun and engaging, though low interaction may not appeal to everyone.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Board Game Hangover

The game is fun throughout, with a sense of escalation and progression.

B

Board Game Hangover

There's low interaction in this game, which might be a problem if you don't enjoy that.

B

Board Game Hangover

The game has charm in spades and is a lovely, absolutely wonderful experience.

w

Whatboardgame.com

5

Twilight Imperium

Score: 8/10

Twilight Imperium

High replayability with numerous factions and strategies, though its length may limit frequent play.

Longevity

8/10

S

Shut Up & Sit Down

Twilight Imperium offers high replayability with its numerous factions and strategic options.

S

Shut Up & Sit Down

The game encourages different playstyles and strategies, keeping it fresh over multiple sessions.

S

Shut Up & Sit Down

The game's length and complexity may deter players from playing frequently.

Complexity

7/10

Twilight Imperium offers a deep strategic experience with diverse gameplay, but its complexity can be overwhelming for new players.

Theme & Design

9/10

The game features a strong thematic presence with detailed art and components, enhancing the space opera experience.

Play Time

6/10

Provides an epic, immersive experience but requires a significant time commitment.

Fun

8/10

Highly engaging with a mix of strategy and thematic elements, though length and complexity may cause downtime.
6

Wingspan

Score: 8/10

Wingspan

High replay value with unique bird cards and strategies, though some end game goals may lack impact.

Longevity

8/10

T

The Dice Tower

Every game of this is going to be different; you're going to get a different hand of bird cards every time.

T

The Dice Tower

I think there are about 160 different cards in this game, and that's a ton.

Complexity

8/10

Wingspan balances strategy and accessibility, suitable for various player levels, though it may be overwhelming for non-gamers.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

Wingspan is a competitive, light strategy game in which each player starts with a hand of birds.

T

The Dice Tower

It's more tactical than strategic, as you don't enter a game knowing what you're going to do for the entire duration.

Theme & Design

9/10

The bird theme is unique and well-executed with high-quality artwork, though some may not find it appealing.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

The artwork and production values bring this theme into the game, which is fantastic.

T

The Dice Tower

The cards are of really good quality, the dice are of good quality, and the eggs are neat.

Play Time

7/10

Relatively quick game suitable for relaxed sessions, though playtime can extend with more players.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

The game is not long; it says 40 to 70 minutes. An hour seems very reasonable for this game.

T

The Dice Tower

It accommodates up to five players. Five is okay, but I think it works really well with two, three, or four.

Fun

8/10

Fun and satisfying with beautiful design, though luck may affect enjoyment for some.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

The game looks fantastic; it's fun to manipulate and place the eggs.

T

The Dice Tower

It feels like your decisions matter, and that is very, very important to me.

7

Root

Score: 8/10

Root

Root's varied factions keep the game fresh and engaging over multiple plays.

Complexity

7/10

Root's complexity offers a deep, asymmetric experience but can be overwhelming for new players.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

Root is a masterpiece in every sense of the word, designed by Cole Worley and put out by Leader Games.

T

The Dice Tower

Root offers different factions that have unique ways of playing, distinct constraints, and various abilities.

T

The Dice Tower

The complexity of the cats makes them the easiest ones to play, considering their card wealth, aggressiveness, and crafting ability.

Theme & Design

9/10

Root features striking art and components that convey a serious tone despite their cute appearance.

Play Time

7/10

Root offers a reasonable playtime of 45-60 minutes, though new players may take longer.

Fun

8/10

Root is fun and accessible, offering unique strategies despite its complexity.
8

Brass: Birmingham

Score: 8/10

Brass: Birmingham

High replayability due to complex mechanics and strategic depth.

Longevity

8/10

N

No Pun Included

Brass Birmingham was already known to be a mathematically robust game that survived a lot of plays.

N

No Pun Included

It is precisely this longevity that pushed brass into the number one spot.

Complexity

9/10

A deeply strategic game requiring careful planning and decision-making.

Theme & Design

8/10

Captures the Industrial Revolution's essence with dual-sided board aesthetics.

Play Time

7/10

Rich experience justifies longer playtime, but not ideal for quick sessions.

Fun

7/10

Satisfying achievement but pressure may not suit all players.
9

Onitama

Score: 8/10

Onitama

Offers replayability with strategic depth, though expansions may feel unnecessary.

Longevity

8/10

T

The Dice Tower

The game offers significant replayability with various card combinations and strategic depth.

T

The Dice Tower

It is a game that players often want to play multiple times in a single sitting.

T

The Dice Tower

The expansions, while adding variety, may not be essential for casual players.

Complexity

8/10

Onitama is easy to learn but offers strategic depth, though expansions can add complexity.

Theme & Design

7/10

Beautiful design with a unique theme, though some find the packaging inefficient.

Play Time

9/10

Quick game, ideal for short sessions and multiple plays.

Fun

8/10

Engaging and fun with strategic depth, though expansions may reduce simplicity.
10

Catan

Score: 8/10

Catan

High replayability with customizable setup and expansions, though base game appeal may diminish.

Longevity

8/10

G

Gather Together Games

The great thing about this game is that these hexes can be arranged in any combination.

G

Gather Together Games

There are expansions and even more expansions to the game.

Complexity

8/10

Catan offers strategic depth with straightforward rules, though it can be slow at times.

Theme & Design

7/10

The game features attractive wooden pieces and customizable board setup, but frame pieces can be problematic.

Play Time

6/10

Allows for social interaction but can be slow if resources are scarce.

Fun

7/10

Interactive and strategic, but pace may not suit everyone.