Best Board Games for Theme And Design (2024)

1

Scythe

Score: 9/10

Scythe

Stunning artwork and unique theme, though some feel the theme doesn't fully translate into gameplay.

Theme And Design

9/10

B

Board Game Hangover

The artwork and design are stunning, featuring intricate details in both the board and the pieces.

B

Board Game Hangover

The theme of an alternate 1920s Europe featuring mechs is unique and well-integrated into the gameplay.

Complexity

8/10

Scythe offers a deep strategic experience with a focus on engine building, though it has a steep learning curve.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Board Game Hangover

The learning curve is pretty intense, so if you are not accustomed to playing strategy, world-building, and engine-building games, there's going to be a learning curve.

B

Board Game Hangover

The game provides a rewarding challenge, as players must learn to optimize their actions and adapt to different faction and player mat combinations.

Longevity

8/10

High replayability with different factions and expansions, but can become repetitive without them.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Board Game Hangover

There is high replayability due to the different factions and player mat combinations, which offer a new challenge with each game.

B

Board Game Hangover

The game can become repetitive after several plays without expansions because the core mechanics remain the same.

Play Time

7/10

Grand scale experience in a short time, but setup can be lengthy.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Board Game Hangover

The game offers a grand-scale experience in a relatively short amount of time, with most games lasting around 115 minutes.

B

Board Game Hangover

The setup time can be lengthy, taking about 45 minutes.

Fun

8/10

Highly enjoyable for strategic planning enthusiasts, but lacks direct conflict.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Board Game Hangover

Scythe is highly enjoyable for those who appreciate strategic planning and engine-building.

B

Board Game Hangover

The lack of direct conflict might not appeal to players who are looking for a more combative experience.

2

Pandemic Legacy: Season 1

Score: 9/10

Pandemic Legacy: Season 1

The game features an evocative theme with a global aspect and engaging design elements, though the permanency of changes can be daunting.

Theme And Design

9/10

S

Shelfside

It's evocative and unpredictable, and the theme is immediately exciting to everyone.

S

Shelfside

Pandemic Legacy is just like Risk Legacy, but with one vitally important difference.

S

Shelfside

You're going to create your own problems and your own twists, and you're going to destroy your own cities.

Complexity

8/10

The game offers a dynamic experience with evolving rules and components, though it can be luck-dependent and confusing for newcomers.

Quotes from Reviewers

S

Shelfside

The legacy aspect adds an almost campaign-like element to the game, which is why it has two designers.

S

Shelfside

The game is divided into months, so you have January, February, March, etc.

S

Shelfside

You can really just have no chance at all of winning because of the luck of the draw.

Longevity

7/10

Offers substantial playtime with a unique campaign, but replayability is limited once completed.

Quotes from Reviewers

S

Shelfside

This means that you'll play between 12 and 24 limited games, and that's it.

S

Shelfside

Your copy of Pandemic Legacy is going to be unique compared to anyone else's in the world.

S

Shelfside

It is much more expensive than during the pandemic; it's probably twice the price, if not more.

Play Time

8/10

Structured into monthly scenarios for flexible play, but limited to the campaign's duration.

Quotes from Reviewers

S

Shelfside

The game is divided into months, so you have January, February, March, etc.

S

Shelfside

We consumed it in the same way we would a TV show, really, and that is by binge-watching.

S

Shelfside

You can play each of these twice. If you fail, you get a second chance to do it.

Fun

8/10

Highly enjoyable with a compelling story, though fixed progression and luck dependency can be frustrating.

Quotes from Reviewers

S

Shelfside

I did like this very much, and I'm really looking forward to the next one.

S

Shelfside

It has that anticipation of what's it going to be, what's it going to be that brings this to life for you.

S

Shelfside

The nature of what is going to happen when things occur is fixed.

3

Harmonies

Score: 9/10

Harmonies

Wingspan features stunning artwork and high-quality components, though its theme may feel abstract.

Theme And Design

9/10

B

Board Game Hangover

The art was the first thing that drew me to this game.

B

Board Game Hangover

The art of this game is a major attraction, and its table presence is simply lovely.

B

Board Game Hangover

The artwork is really beautiful, and the tokens, along with the colorfulness of the terrain, are engaging.

Complexity

7/10

Wingspan is easy to learn with intuitive mechanics, but its strategic elements add a layer of complexity.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Board Game Hangover

This is one of those games that can be taught in less than five minutes.

B

Board Game Hangover

I believe this game is just about perfectly complex for the audience.

B

Board Game Hangover

It's easy to teach, and new gamers can really get into it and have a good time.

Longevity

8/10

Wingspan offers high replayability but may lack long-term challenge without expansions.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Board Game Hangover

It gets better every time you play because you discover new combos.

B

Board Game Hangover

There are limited opportunities, which makes it more challenging.

B

Board Game Hangover

The game has consistently brought happiness to the table.

Play Time

7/10

Wingspan offers a satisfying playtime but can feel long with more players or new learners.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Board Game Hangover

You can play it pretty quickly if you want to.

B

Board Game Hangover

This game can take a little longer, especially if you're teaching new players.

B

Board Game Hangover

A four-player count is doable, but it's a bit slow.

Fun

8/10

Wingspan is fun and engaging, though low interaction may not appeal to everyone.

Quotes from Reviewers

B

Board Game Hangover

The game is fun throughout, with a sense of escalation and progression.

B

Board Game Hangover

There's low interaction in this game, which might be a problem if you don't enjoy that.

B

Board Game Hangover

The game has charm in spades and is a lovely, absolutely wonderful experience.

w

Whatboardgame.com

4

Disney Villainous

Score: 9/10

Disney Villainous

Beautifully incorporates Disney villains with high-quality artwork and design.

Theme And Design

9/10

T

The Dice Tower

The card art is top-notch, as you would imagine, and the villain pawns are almost worth the price of admission on their own.

T

The Dice Tower

The game creators have done an excellent job of developing various objectives, tasks, and ways of playing for each of the villains.

Complexity

7/10

Offers diverse gameplay with unique villains but can be challenging to master.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

Each player chooses their own villain, and each villain has their own objective that they must meet in order to win the game.

T

The Dice Tower

It can be a little difficult to know each villain's objective when you're playing it until you've played it a few times.

T

The Dice Tower

There is a luck-of-the-draw factor because you have cards, and you're playing the hand management aspect of it.

Longevity

7/10

Offers replayability with multiple villains and expansions but may lack depth.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

Overall, there are 15 villains if you have all the expansion packs.

T

The Dice Tower

Having said that some of the villains have easier objectives than others, the balance between them isn't as perfect as it could be.

Play Time

6/10

Best with smaller groups for manageable play time; can be lengthy with more players.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

With smaller accounts, you have enough room to make even tricky plans possible, as the fake cards will come a little less frequently.

T

The Dice Tower

Plus, since turns can take some planning, smaller counts keep things moving at a decent pace, while higher counts have the potential to become a bit more of a marathon.

Fun

8/10

Engaging and fun, especially for Disney fans, but can be frustrating at times.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

This game is not going to be for everyone. As we said earlier, there is a lot of 'take that,' and the whole game is kind of an exercise in frustration by design.

T

The Dice Tower

After all, villains are supposed to be gleefully mean; it's just that you need to know what it is that you're getting into.

5

Twilight Imperium

Score: 9/10

Twilight Imperium

The game features a strong thematic presence with detailed art and components, enhancing the space opera experience.

Theme And Design

9/10

S

Shut Up & Sit Down

The game has a strong thematic presence, with detailed art and components.

S

Shut Up & Sit Down

The design includes a variety of alien races, each with a rich backstory.

S

Shut Up & Sit Down

Some players may find the thematic elements overwhelming or unnecessary.

Complexity

7/10

Twilight Imperium offers a deep strategic experience with diverse gameplay, but its complexity can be overwhelming for new players.

Longevity

8/10

High replayability with numerous factions and strategies, though its length may limit frequent play.

Play Time

6/10

Provides an epic, immersive experience but requires a significant time commitment.

Fun

8/10

Highly engaging with a mix of strategy and thematic elements, though length and complexity may cause downtime.
6

Wingspan

Score: 9/10

Wingspan

The bird theme is unique and well-executed with high-quality artwork, though some may not find it appealing.

Theme And Design

9/10

T

The Dice Tower

The artwork and production values bring this theme into the game, which is fantastic.

T

The Dice Tower

The cards are of really good quality, the dice are of good quality, and the eggs are neat.

Complexity

8/10

Wingspan balances strategy and accessibility, suitable for various player levels, though it may be overwhelming for non-gamers.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

Wingspan is a competitive, light strategy game in which each player starts with a hand of birds.

T

The Dice Tower

It's more tactical than strategic, as you don't enter a game knowing what you're going to do for the entire duration.

Longevity

8/10

High replay value with unique bird cards and strategies, though some end game goals may lack impact.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

Every game of this is going to be different; you're going to get a different hand of bird cards every time.

T

The Dice Tower

I think there are about 160 different cards in this game, and that's a ton.

Play Time

7/10

Relatively quick game suitable for relaxed sessions, though playtime can extend with more players.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

The game is not long; it says 40 to 70 minutes. An hour seems very reasonable for this game.

T

The Dice Tower

It accommodates up to five players. Five is okay, but I think it works really well with two, three, or four.

Fun

8/10

Fun and satisfying with beautiful design, though luck may affect enjoyment for some.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

The game looks fantastic; it's fun to manipulate and place the eggs.

T

The Dice Tower

It feels like your decisions matter, and that is very, very important to me.

7

Root

Score: 9/10

Root

Root features striking art and components that convey a serious tone despite their cute appearance.

Complexity

7/10

Root's complexity offers a deep, asymmetric experience but can be overwhelming for new players.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

Root is a masterpiece in every sense of the word, designed by Cole Worley and put out by Leader Games.

T

The Dice Tower

Root offers different factions that have unique ways of playing, distinct constraints, and various abilities.

T

The Dice Tower

The complexity of the cats makes them the easiest ones to play, considering their card wealth, aggressiveness, and crafting ability.

Longevity

8/10

Root's varied factions keep the game fresh and engaging over multiple plays.

Play Time

7/10

Root offers a reasonable playtime of 45-60 minutes, though new players may take longer.

Fun

8/10

Root is fun and accessible, offering unique strategies despite its complexity.
8

Betrayal at House on the Hill (3rd Edition)

Score: 8/10

Betrayal at House on the Hill (3rd Edition)

Strong horror theme with vivid components, though some may find the quality lacking compared to previous editions.

Theme And Design

8/10

G

Games Made Easy

I love it because it's like you and your friends are suddenly plunged into a Scooby-Doo episode or one of those 50s B movies.

G

Games Made Easy

The Third Edition looks bright and vivid, especially with the 45 tiles appearing more refreshed than before and featuring so much color.

G

Games Made Easy

The component quality is definitely a step down from the previous version. The toes in this edition are a little bit thinner, and the artwork isn't as nice.

Complexity

7/10

The game offers a mix of exploration and strategy with streamlined rules, but can be overwhelming for newcomers.

Quotes from Reviewers

G

Games Made Easy

Betrayal is a bit more complicated than your average gateway game, but it's well worth learning.

G

Games Made Easy

The game has 50 haunt scenarios, and each tells a different story with different victory conditions.

G

Games Made Easy

Some of the rules are still really unclear, and truth be told, if you have a game with all these different permutations, cards, and tiles trying to come together in a cohesive manner, it's going to be very difficult to eliminate all of the ambiguity.

Longevity

8/10

High replayability with various scenarios, though reduced omen cards may impact replay value.

Quotes from Reviewers

G

Games Made Easy

The fact that, as we mentioned, you have 50 haunts, which means you could play this at least 50 times without seeing the same thing, makes it shockingly good value for money.

G

Games Made Easy

With only 9 Omens in the game, you'll frequently draw through most, if not all, of the entire Omen deck every game, putting a damper on repeat value.

Play Time

7/10

Designed for 60-90 minutes, but player elimination can cause downtime.

Quotes from Reviewers

G

Games Made Easy

It's great with three to six players; the more, the merrier, and it'll take about an hour to play.

G

Games Made Easy

Player elimination is still a massive problem in this game. You would think that after, I don't know, was it six different editions, they would have fixed this. However, a lot of the haunts mean that if you die, that's it; you are done.

Fun

8/10

Unique and thematic experience with hidden traitor mechanics, though potential imbalances can affect enjoyment.

Quotes from Reviewers

G

Games Made Easy

A simple and effective role-playing game is guaranteed to make it an evening to remember.

G

Games Made Easy

The haunts can sometimes be free-for-alls; they can have hidden traitors, or they can even be cooperative missions.

9

The Quacks of Quedlinburg

Score: 8/10

The Quacks of Quedlinburg

The magical potion-making theme is unique and engaging, though component durability could be improved.

Theme And Design

8/10

T

The Dice Tower

The game has a very bubbly appearance.

T

The Dice Tower

The white chips, especially since they're used more than any other chips, are really beat up.

Complexity

7/10

The game balances strategy and luck with a mid-weight feel, though it may lack depth for some.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

The Quacks of Quedlinburg isn't going to overwhelm anybody.

T

The Dice Tower

The game has a pleasant mid-weight feel to it.

w

Longevity

7/10

Variety and expansions keep the game fresh, but component wear and reliance on luck may affect long-term appeal.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

You can mix and match them, which, of course, allows the game to have expansions.

T

The Dice Tower

The chip problem is perhaps my only negative aspect of the game.

Play Time

7/10

Simultaneous play reduces downtime, but extended playtime may not suit all players.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

And because the game takes place simultaneously, there's no sitting around and waiting.

T

The Dice Tower

This method of drawing chips from the bag can be used in all previous rounds if you prefer, but it will extend the length of the game.

Fun

8/10

Exciting push-your-luck mechanics offer tension and decision-making, though randomness may frustrate some.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

The quacks at Quellingberg are just straight-up things I find joy in, especially in the whole concept of pushing your luck.

T

The Dice Tower

The game never exists here in this middle zone, where everything is just fine.

10

Sagrada

Score: 8/10

Sagrada

Sagrada features a beautiful stained glass theme with high-quality components, though the theme is not very strong.

Theme And Design

8/10

T

The Dice Tower

This is a really beautiful cover.

T

The Dice Tower

The production in this game is just gorgeous, from the stained glass windows to when it's full of dice.

Complexity

7/10

Sagrada is easy to learn with simple rules but offers strategic depth, though expansions and tool cards can add complexity.

Longevity

6/10

Sagrada is easy to introduce and visually appealing, but may lack depth and replayability for some players.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

For me, it's a game that quickly loses its appeal in terms of decision-making.

T

The Dice Tower

The expansions add a nice touch of life to the game.

Play Time

7/10

Sagrada offers a quick playtime and scales well with 2-4 players, though it can experience downtime.

Quotes from Reviewers

Fun

7/10

Sagrada is engaging and rewarding, offering strategic decisions, though randomness can hinder the fun.

Quotes from Reviewers

T

The Dice Tower

Overall, Sagrada is just a fun game of rolling dice and trying to fulfill different scoring objectives.

T

The Dice Tower

I tend to find the private scoring goals to be overly powerful.